Highway streaming-text messages may not be entertaining, but they’re crucial: “Accident ahead, reduce speed to 20 mph and use alternate Rte. 312 to avoid stalled traffic.”
Many state Departments of Transportation (DOTs) have adopted LED message centers as their preferred highway-traffic management system to inform drivers about current travel conditions. Roadside, LED text messages instantly communicate ongoing, or unsafe, driving conditions and, if necessary, suggest alternate routes.
The sign systems report such roadside incidents as slowdowns, accidents, construction, lane closures, weather concerns, amber alerts and travel-time alerts. Alerts vary from global messages that cover the entire network (amber alerts and posted speed limits) to dedicated messages concerning road incidents along specific routes.
Highway LED electronic systems take many forms. Overhead electronic sign cabinets are suspended on scaffolds across highways. The walk-in sign cabinets allow onsite maintenance without interrupting traffic flow. Signs installed on single-post stanchions supply the same message capabilities as overhead highway signs on arterial, or secondary, roads, which feed traffic to and from major highways. The sign face lifts in sections to provide maintenance access to the interior.
To serve secondary roadsides, LED units can also be towed on mobile trailers to inform travelers about temporary road incidents, such as road construction. Toll-booth signage, which displays collection fees and lane directions, helps manage traffic-funnel locations near bridges and tunnel toll-collection points.
LED message centers have been integrated into highway-traffic management to form a complex, information-gathering network. The Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) program, the U.S. DOT’s initiative to add information technology as a traffic-management component to each state’s transportation infrastructure, helps improve safety and reduces vehicle wear, transportation time and fuel costs.
The U.S. DOT refers to ITS displays as “dynamic message signs” (DMS). State DOTs may describe them as “variable message signs” (VMS) or “changeable message signs” (CMS).
Sign manufacturers who work with DOTs must provide LED sign systems that communicate with the department’s sign-network software program at its command center. The National Transportation Communications for Intelligent Transportation Systems (NTCIP) has issued protocols that define the systems’ interoperability – the manner in which system components work together.
At the Washington state traffic command center, a traffic manager monitors intrastate highway conditions. When roadside accidents affect traffic flow, messages can be posted to the highway region.
The NTCIP protocol establishes a traffic-control standard that allows DOTs to “mix and match” various types of LED sign equipment so they can operate in a common sign network, despite unique manufacturing or operating characteristics.
To understand the roadside-network environment, Georgia’s and Washington’s state DOTs have explained how they maintain and acquire electronic signage to manage traffic. Also, several LED sign manufacturers, who supply VMS signage to the state DOTs, have mapped out their VMS network.
Georgia’s CMS network
The Georgia DOT maintains one of the nation’s oldest and most comprehensive ITS installations. Monica Luck, its public-relations spokesperson, said traffic significantly increased statewide in the late 1980s and early 1990s, and the 1996 Summer Olympics in Atlanta compounded the situation.
By turning to an electronic traffic-management system, the DOT quickly solved how overcrowded state and local roads could safely handle Olympic visitors, plus local residents, through the metro Atlanta area.
The ITS system included television monitors of highway traffic; onsite observers, who dealt with incident management and motorist assistance; ramp meters and weather monitoring.
Overhead VMS signs help coordinate traffic flow when highway conditions change.
The DOT’s NaviGAtor website provided real-time local and regional, 24/7 traffic information. The LED message centers, which Georgia refers to as CMS, synthesized the information to alert drivers about travel incidents and, if they were serious, suggested alternate routes.
Since its Olympic success, Georgia has installed approximately 97 permanent CMS units throughout the state, Luck said.
“As our metro-Atlanta population has grown [100,000 new residents are added yearly], we can accommodate expanding traffic, not by building more roads, but by improving our ability to manage existing roads with better, information-deployment systems. Our goal is to place individual CMS, LED sign units where we think they’ll do the most good.”
The metro Atlanta area is the central hub for most Georgia highways. At least two major interstate routes, I-75 and I-85, feed Midwest and Eastern Seaboard traffic through the downtown Atlanta area.
Incidents that occur in nearby states also affect Georgia’s traffic, Luck noted. “Although we’re not directly affected by hurricane weather, we’re affected from a by-product of that weather. Many evacuees from the Florida Panhandle come here when displaced by a hurricane. To deal with that, we’ve placed CMS units in southeast and southwest Georgia to provide Floridian evacuees up-to-date traffic and evacuation information as they travel north towards through Georgia,” Luck said.
Washington state’s VMS
Washington state’s DOT operations engineer Bill Legg said his state began retrofitting existing sign cabinets in 1992 by replacing sign faces with early-model LED electronic signs.
Asked if the state’s roadside electronic signage is enough, Legg replied, “We find that ‘enough’ is a tricky word. How we place our VMS network is defined, in some instances, by how traffic activity rearranges itself [new travel patterns]; by road conditions, such as construction; or by location, like mountain passes, where weather can go through very quick extreme changes.”
Legg said the state’s electronic sign system proves its effectiveness. “When we post travel-time alerts or amber alerts,” Legg said, “we get many responses, so we know that people are paying attention.”
For new orders, the state specifies the types of signs it needs and defines the required performance capabilities and operability to work with its existing, central-control system. The state then allows the appropriate LED sign manufacturers to bid on the project.
Legg said, “We select a vendor, and, having done that, any one of Washington’s six operational regions that needs to add new VMS units can buy off the selected vendor list to fulfill its specific VMS needs.”
Daktronics
Daktronics Inc. (Brookings, SD), an LED sign manufacturer that offers commercial and sports LED-sign product lines, has provided LED signs to the DOT community since 1988.
Its family of ITS-based, LED sign systems, called Vanguard variable-message signs, includes overhead, walk-in sign cabinets; arterial, secondary-roadside signs; and a mobile trailer for road-construction and lane-closure alerts. The Vanguard signs deliver full-matrix and full-color capabilities, which enable such graphics and symbols as merging, traffic-lane symbols or the disability graphic (a blue background with a white wheelchair symbol).
In a secondary, traffic-management situation, Daktronics also offers toll-booth, lane-control signage and parking-lot price and lot-status indicator signage.
In conjunction with its Vanguard line, Daktronics also offers DOTs an NTCIP-compliant, software-management system that controls VMS signage that’s within a state-highway system. The software’s message-scheduling function allows traffic-management users to edit and change sign messages in real time, and it provides self-diagnostics of the entire LED sign network. It monitors and simultaneously interfaces with various roadside-communication systems, such as telephone, cellular, fiberoptic and radio-communication setups.
Because of a VMS network’s critical importance to highway safety, LED outdoor sign-manufacturing processes must meet more rigorous fabricating demands than typical commercial signs. Tom Becker, Daktronics’ ITS market manager, noted a few of the robust, DOT requirements for an ITS, NTCIP environment:
• Special welding standards are based on American Welding Standards guidelines.
• Structural standards for wind loading, ice loading and hurricane gust level are more demanding than commercial-level requirements.
• Redundant power-supply support is required.
• A high level of self-diagnostics must exist.
• Performance capabilities must demonstrate interoperability NTCIP compliance.
• The 9,000-nit, sign-brightness level far exceeds typical outdoor, commercial, brightness levels (usually 5,000 nits).
Government bureaucracy often lengthens the acquisition process. Becker said, “In the commercial world, the decisionmaking process moves pretty quickly in regard to sign purchases. In the DOT world, a more bureaucratic acquisition process requires a longer lead time for the DOTs in getting their VMS signs for interstate use.”
Adaptive Micro Systems
Another VMS supplier, Adaptive Micro Systems Inc. (Milwaukee), designs, develops and fabricates indoor and outdoor LED signs. Adaptive’s vice president, Ron Levac, said transportation became one of the company’s market applications when “we saw that outdoor LED signs were the perfect technology for the DOT’s ITS market, in terms of replacing the older, electro-mechanical, flip-disk technology.”
The company introduced its AlphaXpress signs as a highway sign system to DOTs nationwide. The VMS sign line includes overhead, walk-in cabinets and the smaller, arterial roadside signs.
Adaptive applies the DOT’s stringent manufacturing and operating standards — redundant power supplies, pixel-failure diagnostics and a ventilation system that manages the sign’s ambient operating temperatures – to its VMS-manufactured signage. NTCIP compliance allows AlphaXpress signage to fit within all DOT interoperability standards. AlphaXpress has been sold to most DOTs nationwide.
At the 2006 ITS America (sponsored by the Intelligent Transportation Society of America, Washington, DC), the company introduced a unique browser interface that allows service personnel to diagnose and service a VMS with any browser-enabled device.
Adaptive Micro Systems’ (Milwaukee) AlphaXpress sign was installed along a new highway route.
Dashboard signage?
VMS’ potential traffic-management effectiveness will be enhanced by once and future technology. Most electronic signs are networked via landlines, but wireless may become the new connectivity standard between LED signs and the various DOT traffic-command centers. Additional color and graphic capabilities will enhance driver/traffic-management communications.
After some crystal-ball gazing, Washington state’s Legg noted that vehicles already feature electronic-navigation systems that provide on-board maps, but, in the future, he predicts vehicles’ dedicated display panels will pick up electronic ITS sign messages and replay them on the dashboard. This wouldn’t replace LED highway signage, but “CMS” may change its meaning from “changeable message systems” to “car message systems.”